Holle Goat Formula vs. HiPP Goat Formula

If you're here reading this article, chances are you've already made the great choice to opt for goat milk formula for your baby. Congratulations because we also love Goat Formula! Goat milk baby formula is a wonderfully nutritious option with several features that can benefit your little one. In this parent-friendly guide, we'll dive into the Holle Goat formulas and HiPP Goat formulas we carry and give you a detailed comparison and insights into these European organic goat milk formulas.

What Is Goat Milk Formula?

Before we dive into the different formulas, we must ask ourselves: what exactly is Organic Goat Milk Formula? Goat milk formula is an infant formula made from goat’s milk instead of cow’s milk. It is formulated to meet the nutritional needs of babies who are exclusively formula-fed or require supplemental feeding in addition to breastfeeding.

Goat infant formula packs a powerful blend of essential nutrients vital for a baby's growth and development. You'll find a balanced mix of protein, fat, carbohydrates, vitamins, and minerals within each serving, including the important iron component. These elements work harmoniously to give your little one everything they need to thrive.

Safety First for Newborns
Now, when it comes to newborns, safety is paramount. With decades of manufacturing experience, Rest assured that Holle and Hipp Organic Goat Milk Formulas are a safe choice for your little one. Recent research has demonstrated that goat milk formula for newborns performs admirably when fostering growth and safety. It's a reassuring testament to the quality and suitability of this formula for our tiniest family members.

A Gentle Solution
So, what makes goat milk formula so special? Well, it's all about being gentle, especially for those babies who may have trouble with cow's milk. Some infants may experience cow's milk intolerance or digestive discomfort. This is where goat's milk formula shines, as it's often considered a more easily digestible alternative. It's like a soothing balm for those sensitive little tummies.

A Formula for All Babies
But here's the kicker: Goat milk formula isn't exclusively designed for babies with sensitive digestive systems. While it can be a lifesaver for them, it's important to note that goat milk formula isn't a hypoallergenic formula. It's crafted to meet the nutritional needs of all babies, ensuring that they all receive a balanced and nourishing start in life.

In essence, goat milk formula offers a versatile and nutrient-packed option for parents seeking an alternative to cow's milk-based formulas. Whether it's due to allergies, digestive ease, or simply a preference, goat milk formula is here to support your parenting journey.

Please note:
Breastmilk is best for your baby. However, it is not always possible for all parents or caregivers to breastfeed their babies. Before changing your baby's diet, consult your trusted pediatrician to ensure you make the best choice for your little one's well-being!

What Sets Goat Milk Formula Apart from Cow's Milk Formula?

Regarding goat milk formula versus cow's milk formula, there are more similarities than differences in their nutritional content. Both types of formula provide a well-balanced blend of essential vitamins, minerals, proteins, fats, and carbohydrates that are vital for your baby's healthy growth and development. However, there are a few distinctive features that may lead you to consider goat milk-based formula as the preferred choice for your baby:

Fat Globules:
Goat milk stands out with its smaller fat globules, which are rich in medium-chain fatty acids. In contrast, cow's milk contains more long-chain fatty acids, which can pose a greater challenge for your baby's developing digestive system. Goat milk's composition aligns more closely with what your baby's body can readily process.

Protein Composition: Goat milk boasts A2 casein protein, while cow's milk typically contains A1 casein protein. Many experts suggest that A2 protein is easier to digest, potentially reducing the likelihood of digestive discomfort for your baby.

Lactose Levels: Goat milk contains less lactose than cow's milk, making it a gentler option for digestion, especially for babies with lactose intolerance. This can mean a happier and more comfortable tummy for your little one.

Ethical and Sustainable Choice: Beyond nutrition, goat milk is a more ethical and sustainable alternative to cow's milk. Raising goats typically demands less land, water, and feed than cows to produce the same quantity of milk. Choosing goat milk formula can reflect your commitment to responsible and environmentally conscious choices.

Holle Bio Goat Formula vs. Hipp Organic Goat Formula

Let’s get back to the topic of this blog and explain the differences between these two brands and their products. If you're considering your options between Holle and HiPP goat milk formulas, it's essential to understand the unique characteristics of each brand. Let's take a closer look at what sets them apart:

Holle Goat Formula: Holle has earned a reputation as the "clean" goat milk formula, known for its simple ingredient composition. With a history of almost nine decades and a consistent presence in the market, Holle is considered a pioneer in the world of goat milk formulas. They even offer a "Goat PRE" version suitable for premature babies, a feature not found in the HiPP formulas. Holle Goat Dutch formula is manufactured with grass-fed goats raised on Demeter farms. Demeter-certified biodynamic farms use the world’s most sustainable farming practices to ensure their products are full of love, care, and nutrition. Besides safe products, biodynamic farmers ensure their animals are raised in caring environments.

All stages of Holle Goat formula are formulated with strict EU regulations, ensuring high standards for the safety of organic ingredients and high animal care standards. We carry the German Version of the Holle Goat formulas packaged in 400-gram carton boxes and the Dutch Holle Goat Version packaged in handy stackable cans of 800 grams. For every formula we carry, we have English Nutrition And Feeding Charts. 

Why Holle Goat?

• No artificial additives
• It boasts a higher concentration of iron (compared to HiPP Goat), which can contribute to your baby's brain and neurological development. Iron is a crucial component of hemoglobin, which helps transport oxygen in the blood.
• Certified organic by the European Commission
• Demeter certified
• Contains essential nutrients, ensuring they are safe and healthy for your baby.
• No genetic engineering or modification with GMOs (genetically modified organisms).
• Contains all the necessary ingredients, including A2 milk, calcium, vitamins A, C, and D, and healthy fatty acids.

Parent Review
I was researching and looking for the best formula for my baby.
I think that Holle Goat is a very good product. The milk smells like real milk and it tastes good. The taste is very similar to the breastmilk. My baby loves it! The delivery was fast. I received my package in time.

Organic Formula Shop offers The Holle Bio Goat in German and Dutch versions.  

Holle Goat Dutch Stages:
Organic Formula Shop offers The Holle Goat Dutch formula in 3 stages:

Holle Goat Dutch Formula - Stage 1

• Appropriate from birth to 6 months
• No Palm Oil, Soy Oil, or Added Sugar
• Free from artificial chemicals, preservatives, and flavors
• The main carbohydrate is lactose sourced from Whole Organic Goat's milk 
• Goats are kept by EU Organic Regulations
• Biodynamic, Demeter, and Organic Certified (one of the most stringent organic certifications in the world) 
• Reinforced container for better stacking

Holle Goat Dutch Formula - Stage 2

• Designed for babies aged 6 to 10 months
• No Palm Oil, Soy Oil, or Added Sugar
• Free from artificial chemicals, preservatives, and flavors
• The main carbohydrate is lactose sourced from Whole Organic Goat's milk
• Biodynamic, Demeter, and Organic Certified (one of the most stringent organic certifications in the world) 

Holle Goat Dutch Formula - Stage 3

• Suitable from 10 months onwards 
• Gluten-Free and GMO-Free
• No Palm Oil, Soy Oil, or Added Sugar 
• Free from artificial chemicals, preservatives, and flavors
• Goats are kept by EU Organic Regulations
• Biodynamic, Demeter, and Organic Certified (one of the most stringent organic certifications in the world) 

Holle Goat German Stages
Organic Formula Shop offers The HiPP Goat German formula in 5 stages:

Holle Organic Goat Formula - Stage Pre

•  For babies from 0 to 6 months
  •    easy-to-digest formula for babies with cow milk sensitivities
  •    Organic milk from happy goats!
  •    No added sugar, No starch, No gluten, and no GMOs
  •    Prebiotics & probiotics + Omega 3 & 6
  •    Essential vitamins and nutrients
  •    Clean formula similar to breast milk
  •    Made in Germany for the German Market.
  •    Certified Organic to European standards

Holle Organic Goat Formula - Stage 1

 

• Suitable from birth onwards
• Whole organic goat milk
• Great option when cow's milk is not tolerated well
• No artificial preservatives, chemicals, flavors, and no soy
• Goats are kept by EU organic regulations
• No genetically modified ingredients
• Chemical-Free Agriculture and Production
• Certified to EU standards

Holle Organic Goat Formula - Stage 2

• Suitable from six months onwards
• Whole organic goat milk
• Great option when cow's milk is not tolerated well
• No artificial preservatives, chemicals, flavors, or colors
• No soy & GMO-free
• Chemical-free agriculture and Organically Grown Ingredients
• Contains DHA
• Certified to EU standards

Holle Organic Goat Formula - Stage 3

• Suitable from 10 months onwards
• Premium Quality Organic Baby Food
• Organically Grown Ingredients
• EU Organic Regulations keep goats
• No Genetically Modified Ingredients
• No Artificial Chemicals or Preservatives
• No Artificial Flavors or Colors
• Chemical-Free Agriculture and Production
• Certified to EU standards

Why HiPP Goat Formula?

Another great vegetarian-friendly formula option for your baby is the HiPP Goat Formula, which is derived from grass-fed goats. HiPP is known for its goat milk formula with helpful additives, particularly prebiotics. These prebiotics play a vital role in maintaining the health of infants. Although HiPP is a relatively newer player in the goat milk formula market, decades of preliminary product research enabled them to introduce one of the most advanced and robust goat milk products available.  The Hipp Dutch Goat Formulas come in handy stackable cans of 400 grams.

Unique Components:

• HiPP Goat formula contains inositol, a compound not found in its Holle counterpart. Inositol isn't used for energy but serves as a building block for other compounds.
• Galacto-oligosaccharide (GOS) is exclusive to the HiPP Goat formula. Studies have shown that GOS can selectively stimulate the development of beneficial Bifidobacteria in the gut.

 
Organic Formula Shop offers The HiPP Goat Dutch formula in two stages:

HiPP Dutch Goat Formula - Stage 1

• Great for babies from 0 - 6 months
• Essential (non-synthetic) vitamins and minerals
• From A2 goat milk: Goat milk is naturally rich in A2 beta-casein
• No Soy, GMOs, or Added Sugar
• Contains essential non-synthetic vitamins like Vitamin A, D, E, K, C, B1, B2, and B12
• Rich in DHA/Omega-3, which is important for brain and nerve cell development

HiPP Dutch Goat Formula - Stage 2

• Great for babies from 6 to 12 months of age
• Essential (non-synthetic) vitamins and minerals
• Prebiotics for a healthy gut flora
• From A2 goat milk: Goat milk is naturally rich in A2 beta-casein
• No Soy, GMOs, or Added Sugar
• Contains essential non-synthetic vitamins like Vitamin A, D, E, K, C, B1, B2, and B12
• Rich in Omega-3 (DHA & ALA), which is essential for brain and nerve cell development

What Are the Advantages of Goat's Milk?

Now that we highlighted the various formulas let's explore some well-established benefits of goat's milk, particularly in the context of the Holle Goat and HiPP Goat formulas:

1. Reduced Lactose: If your little one struggles with lactose intolerance, goat's milk can be a gentle alternative. It contains lower levels of lactose compared to cow's milk.
2. Anti-Inflammatory Properties: Goat's milk has a smoother composition than cow's milk and is less likely to cause inflammation. This makes goat's milk formula an appealing choice when your little one experiences bowel inflammation. Its ease of digestion and nutritional benefits make it a safer and more suitable option for newborns. Importantly, goat's milk contains no components that could trigger inflammation in your baby's digestive system.
3. Nutritional Richness: Goat's milk is a nutritional powerhouse, providing essential nutrients for your baby's growth and development. It contains approximately 35% calcium and offers around 9 grams of protein per cup, surpassing cow's milk in this regard. Goat's milk also boasts higher levels of vitamin A, vitamin C (cow's milk contains none), magnesium, vitamin B1, and significantly more potassium. These nutrients contribute to the healthy development of vital organs and support the nervous system. Additionally, goat's milk is associated with joint health due to its "bio-organic sodium animal" reputation.
4. Absence of Synthetic Hormones: Organic goat's milk formulas typically avoid the use of synthetic hormones. These hormones can be problematic for infants, potentially exacerbating issues like lactose intolerance and indigestion. In its natural form, goat's milk is free from genetic modifications and additives, ensuring your baby receives pure and wholesome nutrients.
5. Immune System Enhancement: Goat's milk is an excellent source of selenium, a vital mineral known to modulate and bolster the immune system. As a caring parent, you naturally wish to shield your baby from illnesses, and the trace amounts of selenium in goat's milk can contribute to this protective effect.

In Summary

Holle and HiPP goat milk formulas each have their unique strengths and characteristics. Both brands are committed to providing the best ingredients; your choice ultimately depends on your baby's unique needs and preferences. Remember that the best formula is the one that suits your baby's digestion, tastes good to them, and aligns with your values as a parent. Whichever formula you choose, rest assured that both Holle and HiPP prioritize your baby's well-being by offering high-quality, organic options. Your baby's health and happiness are what truly matter, and with either of these formulas, you're well on your way to providing the best start in life.

Need help deciding which formula to choose? Please check our baby formula comparison chart to help you understand the differences between our offered formulas. 

Any Questions?

Our customer success team has earned hundreds of 5-star reviews from customers dedicated to helping you provide the best nutrition for your little one. Contact us here or shoot us an email at support@organicformulashop.com. 

 Happy Feeding!

Please note: Before changing your baby's diet, always consult with your healthcare provider to ensure the formula you choose fits your infant. 

FAQs About Goat Milk Formula

What Are the Benefits of Goat's Milk Formula?
Several benefits set goat's milk apart from cow's milk.
Digestibility: Goat's milk has smaller fat globules, lower lactose content, and A2 milk proteins than cow's milk. These factors can make it easier for some infants to digest.

Natural Prebiotics: Goat's milk contains oligosaccharides, which are prebiotics supporting the growth of beneficial gut bacteria in infants. (Although many cow's milk formulas also incorporate this prebiotic).

Sustainability: Goat's milk production is more environmentally sustainable than cow's milk production, requiring less land, water, and feed resources.

Can Babies Drink Goat Milk?
No, regular plain goat milk is not suitable for babies aged 0-12 months. Goat milk baby formula, however, is specially modified to meet the nutritional needs of babies, with adjustments made for vitamins, salts, and water content. This same distinction applies to cow's milk versus cow's milk formula. Babies under 12 months should not consume regular cow's milk but can safely have cow's milk formula. After turning 1, babies can incorporate goat milk into their diets as their digestive systems mature to handle it.

Is Goat Milk Closest to Breastmilk? What Formula is Closest to Breastmilk?
While goat milk shares some similarities with breastmilk, both goat milk and cow milk are more akin to each other than either is to breastmilk. Goat milk offers advantages like high natural prebiotics, protein levels similar to human breast milk, and low lactose content. However, it doesn't match the whey-to-casein ratio of breastmilk and isn't nutritionally complete for infants without modification. To bridge this gap, both goat and cow milk must be fortified and adjusted when turned into baby formula to mimic breastmilk's composition closely.

Is Goat's Milk Formula Safe for Babies?
Yes, goat's milk formula designed for infants and meeting the FDA or European Commission nutritional standards for baby formula is safe for your baby to consume. It's essential to consult with your pediatrician before introducing any new formula.

Please note: Before changing your baby's diet, always consult with your healthcare provider to ensure the formula you choose fits your infant.